“High Tech” medicine, excessive therapy and undignified death

Authors

  • Cristina Lima Assistente Hospitalar Graduada de Medicina Interna Serviço de Medicina I do Hospital de Curry Cabral, Lisboa

Keywords:

Ethics, Undignified Death, Therapeutic futility

Abstract

Hipocratic medicine already had as objectives, not only to cure but
also to relieve suffering, condemning at the same time, obviously pointless treatment.
In the latter half of the 20th century the health of the individual
has become a kind of religion in which the use of high technology
is not always adjusted to the patient who is nearing the end of life
but keeps being submitted to treatments to prolong it, transforming the final stages of life into an agonising dying process. This is
always associated with therapeutic futility including the trend to
defi ne the extent of treatment according to available resources.
The article concludes that it is necessary to recover the objectives of Hipocratic medicine which place value on the person, their
values and choices; to recognize when curative medicine should be replaced by palliative.
The article ends by drawing attention to Portugal and the
guidelines issued in 1995 by the Conselho Nacional de Ética
(National Council of Ethics) para as Ciencias da vida about the
ethical aspects of health care related to the end of life.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Hippocrates, Encyclopedia Internacional, Grolier Incorporated, New York 1963;8:452- 453.

Amundsen DW. The physician’s obligation to prolong life: a medical duty without classical roots. Hasting Center Report, v.8, p.23-30 in, Leo Pessini. Distanásia até quando prolongar a vida? S. Paulo, Brasil, Ed. Loyola 2001:144.

Celsus. De medicina 5, 26, 1, c apud Amundsen, D. W. op. cit., p.25, Leo Pessini, Distanásia até quando prolongar a vida? S. Paulo, Brasil, Ed. Loyola 2001:145.

Robertson, J. M. The philosophical works of Francis Bacon, pp.485-49, in, Leo Pessini, Distanásia até quando prolongar a vida? S. Paulo, Brasil, Ed. Loyola 2001:147-148.

Instituto Nacional de Estatísitca-Indicadores de saúde; http//ine.pt/prodserv/indicadore, cons. em 2 Junho de 2005

Francis Fukuyama, O nosso futuro pós-humano, Lisboa, Ed Quetzal 2002:113.

Conselho Nacional de Ética para as ciências da vida. Parecer sobre aspectos éticos dos cuidados de saúde relacionados com o fim da vida, documentação, in, Leo Pessini. Distanásia até quando prolongar a vida? S. Paulo, Brasil, Ed. Loyola 2001:106

Additional Files

Published

2006-06-30

How to Cite

1.
Lima C. “High Tech” medicine, excessive therapy and undignified death. RPMI [Internet]. 2006 Jun. 30 [cited 2024 Dec. 18];13(2):79-82. Available from: https://revista.spmi.pt/index.php/rpmi/article/view/1629

Issue

Section

Original Articles